John is actually reluctant to obfuscate the difficulty also this much inside the Sherlock’s exposure. John allows Sherlock faith he or she is straight, but the guy never closes that home completely: odd decisions to own an effective heterosexual kid, but surely sensible getting good bisexual child which is searching for a romance having Sherlock and you will expectations Sherlock might alter his mind. And while John can’t ever knowingly say “I am not gay” within earshot off Sherlock, Sherlock really does overhear John point out that to Irene in the A great Scandal inside Belgravia – and John attempts to have a discussion about it which have Sherlock, that is shut down.
Think about, John is ready to destroy visitors to sit close Sherlock, thus needless to say he’d become happy to mask their sex also
Better, to begin with, Sherlock seemed to very hate the thought of John getting lured so you can your. It seems sensible John carry out only day females to save Sherlock out-of acquiring the feeling. And additionally, if the John attempted to big date guys they’d assume he was selecting Sherlock, yet not unfairly. It will make the essential sense to have John so far females, in which he does not appear to have an issue with they. (Regardless if, become reasonable, with John you could potentially not sure.) It’s easy to own bisexual individuals alive heterosexual lifetime: many people are heterosexual and you will assume everyone else is also, thus heterosexual matchmaking opportunities pop-up without needing to become desired out.
But as to the reasons was not John currently discover about it, and why really does he obfuscate the situation so you can his brother and you may Statement Murray? Really, you can find ideas in order to much more factors during these very early blog site entries. John try also known as a female guy prior to getting mailed aside to Afghanistan, and in The unmistakeable sign of Three we’re presented the type off Big Sholto, one just who John considerably admires and has now a number of the exact same unsociable services Sherlock has actually; probably the caretaker in John was attracted to people who seem emotionally wounded and you can skittish.
As well as in wide conditions, it will be unsurprising when the John’s gay front concerned this new fore as he was a student in new military and mostly in the middle of people – as well as, on the Sign of Three we are going to be provided with significant gay connectivity to the military, and Big Sholto specifically. As well as, the fresh new inform you have a tendency to bolster more than once one sex try crucial that you John. If the John possess one interest after all to help you men, it’s not unrealistic to trust he would act on it during the an enthusiastic environment in which there are couple available people.
The quintessential telling thing, however, is that John’s listeners of these “I’m not gay” moments has never been Sherlock, actually despite the fact Sherlock consider John are striking for the him in the 1st event and folks continually assume these are generally one or two
Just what exactly happened from inside the Afghanistan? We do not understand, however it is definitely not hard to imagine. Maybe John did not can operate inside, and he will not learn how to pick. Possibly it had been unrequited, in which he feels unfortunate otherwise bad contemplating unsociable males. Maybe it was requited and you will finished improperly. Perhaps the guy performed work involved however, there clearly was tension in order to ensure that it it is secret and you will, which have just returned on the combat, he’s not most yes how to go about are unlock from the it offered his past profile and his awesome old friends are odd about any of it – perhaps not an unusual matter in the event you emerge later on in lives, and Costs and you may Harry apparently discover the tip funny. And work out a tale in regards to the indisputable fact that John might be homosexual was not the most sensitive and painful environment they may possess built when the John wanted to emerge. Or at least John told himself it absolutely was only because females weren’t readily available, but he’s beginning to realize perhaps it had been more that. Maybe he does favor ladies, and you will men have to be a present. Possibly the guy wants people; John appears happy sufficient as he learns away from Mary’s pregnancy 
into the The hallmark of Around three. It isn’t after all uncommon to possess bisexual people to own gender that have boys but merely realize matchmaking that have lady therefore.